Big Jim's Pizza Co.

Vitamin Pets 3 weeks ago

First, the food: A disgrace to pizza. I ordered a margherita and the BBQ chicken. Margherita was bland beyond bland, unseasoned sauce, plastic slabs of untextured mozzarella, sparse, lifeless basil, and soggy, chewy, floppy dough. Took it home and tried to revive it in the oven on a pizza stone to no avail -- dead on arrival. 4.5/10 only because I was desperately hungry. Speaking of desperation -- the BBQ chicken pizza was the sort of concoction that finds you at your lowest and promises to pick you up to somewhere just a tick or two south of substandard. If that sentence doesn't make much sense, neither did the stripes of yellow government-grade cheese that snuck their way into this melange of oversauced floppy slop. I closed my eyes and gave it a 5.3/10 because at least it wasn't pretending to be a margherita. The service: Great crew of hardworking kids, can't fault them at all. Atmosphere: Odd as the front door was locked, side door was open and no one was around when I came in, save for a giant picture of Paulie Walnuts adorning the wall in one of the darkened corrodors beyond the takeout bar. In honor of Mr. Walnuts, if you're thinking about eating here: FUGGHEDABOUDITT

Ray Keller a month ago

I might be biased we were in Chicago a few weeks ago, but it didn't seem like there was any cheese, or very much meat, we ordered meatballs pepperoni and ham. I really only saw the meatballs. The sauce was a little bland but okay. The crust was super thin and required a knife to cut it. We were very disappointed. The other pizzas we get here are great. I'll never waste $40 on this Chicago style pizza from here. The staff was extremely friendly, but we didn't eat this until we got home.

Kind House Ukraine Bakery Charity Fund 2 months ago

If you haven’t eaten here, YOU ARE MISSING OUT!!! Definitely have the macaroni cheese bites!!!! Holy cow this place is great. Ask for Logan. ♥️

Giovani Alvarez 2 months ago

I LOVE this place! The food is amazing, the drinks are reasonably priced and the pizzas of the month are ALWAYS good, always! Get here, buy the food, repeat! Trust!

Brenna 3 months ago

My boyfriend and I decided that we wanted to try this place as a reward for getting through final exams. They did not disappoint! Not only was the pizza phenomenal and everything we hoped it would be, but they also did a split pizza with two speciality pizzas for us. We got half jalapeño popper and half macaroni & cheese, and I’m obsessed. Such unique flavors encompassed perfectly in just one slice. We will be coming back!